Gas vs Wood Burning Fire Pits: How to Decide
Explore the differences between wood burning and gas fire pits to choose the best style for your outdoor space
By: Jeff O'Keefe, NFI Certified Master Hearth Professional
Last Updated: February 27, 2025
Adding a fire pit to your backyard or patio is one of the best ways to create a cozy, inviting outdoor living space. Imagine settling into an outdoor couch or chair with your favorite drink next to warm, glowing flames! Whether you’re hosting friends, relaxing with family, or simply unwinding after a long day, having a fire pit makes every occasion more comfortable.
There are two different types of fire pits to choose from — wood burning and gas. To make your final decision, you’ll need to factor in cost, convenience, environmental impact, and overall aesthetic.
Use this guide to weigh the pros and cons of wood and gas fire pits, so you can determine which style best fits your outdoor space and lifestyle.
Wood Fire Pits: Traditional & Rustic
Pros
🔥 Authentic Experience – It’s hard to beat the crackling sound, smoky aroma, and natural glow of a real wood fire.
🔥 High BTU Output – Wood fire pits burn extremely hot, making them ideal for colder climates and extended use.
🔥 Lower Upfront Cost – Purchasing a wood fire pit is generally more affordable than gas, with many DIY and portable options available.
🔥 Versatile Fuel Source – Firewood is widely available. You can use a variety of different seasoned hardwoods, like oak, maple, pine, elm, and hickory.
Cons
❌ More Maintenance – Ash and soot require regular cleanup, and firewood needs proper storage to stay dry. Consider stacking your logs on a firewood rack to keep them organized, dry, and ready to burn.
❌ Smoke & Sparks – While the scent and sounds of burning logs is appealing to many, wood fire pits produce smoke and stray embers, which can create a fire hazard in windy conditions.
❌ Longer Start-Up & Cool-Down – Wood fires take time to build and extinguish properly.
❌ Restricted Use – Some urban areas have fire bans or restrictions on wood burning fire pits due to air quality concerns.
Wood Fire Pits are Best For:
- People who enjoy a classic campfire feel.
- Homeowners with ample outdoor space and proper fire safety clearance.
- Those who don’t mind extra maintenance for a more traditional experience.
Gas Fire Pits: Modern & Convenient
Pros
🔥 Instant Ignition – With the push of a button or turn of a knob, gas fire pits provide immediate flames and heat. Some gas fire pits even offer convenient, electronic ignition systems with hand-held remotes and smart controls.
🔥 Clean Burning – Gas fire pits don’t produce any smoke, ash, or soot, making for a mess-free experience.
🔥 Customizable Designs – You can choose from a variety of styles to match your outdoor space. You can also upgrade your gas fire pit with different media, like decorative stones and fire glass, for a custom burning display.
🔥 Safer & More Controlled – There won’t be any flying embers, and you can easily adjust the flame intensity.
Cons
❌ Higher Upfront Cost – Gas fire pits, especially those requiring a Natural Gas hookup, are more expensive to install than wood fire pits.
❌ Fuel Supply Dependency – Propane tanks need refilling and Natural Gas requires a fixed connection, limiting your fire pit’s portability.
❌ Potential Gas Leaks – It’s important to make sure all the parts of your gas fire pit are operating correctly, otherwise you could experience a dangerous gas leak. You’ll need to clean and inspect your fire pit regularly.
Gas Fire Pits are Best For:
- Those who prioritize convenience and easy maintenance.
- Urban dwellers with fire restrictions on wood burning.
- People who prefer a sleek, modern aesthetic for their outdoor space.
Making the Final Decision
When choosing between a wood or gas fire pit, consider the following:
✅ Do you prioritize convenience over authenticity? Gas fire pits are easier to use, while wood burning models provide a more natural experience.
✅ How much heat do you need? Wood fires burn hotter, making them better for colder regions.
✅ What’s your budget? Wood fire pits are generally cheaper upfront, while gas options require more investment but lower long-term maintenance.
✅ Are there local fire regulations? Some areas ban wood burning fire pits, making gas the only legal option.
✅ How much maintenance are you willing to do? If you dislike cleaning ash or chopping wood, gas is the hassle-free choice.
We’re Here to Help
Do you have more questions about fire pits? Talk with an NFI certified expert today at 800.919.1904.
More Resources
Check out our expert tips for finding the perfect fire pit for your space.
Find out if it’s safe to put a fire pit on your wood deck.
Want to build your own fire pit? Here are three easy DIY kits.
 |
Jeff O'Keefe is a skilled Technical Sales Representative with a decade of experience at Woodland Direct. As an NFI-Certified Master Hearth Professional, Jeff has helped clients complete a variety of projects, from selecting a fire pit to customizing an indoor fireplace. When he's not working, Jeff escapes to The Great Outdoors. He enjoys exploring new hiking trails, fishing, hunting, and dirt biking. His love for adventure and the outdoors is reflected in his passion for creating warm, inviting spaces that bring people together. Call Jeff or one of our experts in fire at 800.919.1904. |